This is the way the bond world has worked for thousands of years. In fact, as shown in Figure Two, scholars can trace the interest rates on bond issuances as far back as B. As a larger share of the global bond market flips into negative interest rate territory, we have seen some shocking headlines.
Here is a scenario to help illustrate how such a bizarre event could occur. If the coupon on a year U. Treasury was 1. Because the entirety of your initial investment was returned to you, the total return on this bond is represented by the annual coupon payments, and you would have enjoyed a yield of 1. Now imagine you are a bond investor in Germany, where interest rates have turned negative. Instead of paying par for a 1. In this case, the total return of the bond is not equal to the 1. Even if the bond math illustrated above makes sense, an important question remains: Why would a rational investor choose to buy this value-eating, negative-yielding bond?
There could be several reasons:. Central banks, such as the U.
Negative Yields Versus Negative Coupon Rates | Global Macro Monitor
Lower interest rates make it less expensive for borrowers to borrow and provide less incentive for savers to hoard cash. As shown in Figure Three, the Federal Reserve began to cut short-term interest rates in , taking the fed funds rate from 5. The ECB followed suit, cutting its short-term rate from 3.
Although their policy actions were similar, the results of these actions in the U. Monetary stimulus, combined with the more dynamic economic underpinnings in the U. By , with an unemployment rate of 5 percent—down from 10 percent in —and inflation beginning to reemerge, the Federal Reserve had begun to reverse course and raise rates. Facing the challenges of a less dynamic economy, demographic headwinds, and continued bank weakness, the response to rate reductions in Europe was less robust.
European banks, still struggling to rebuild their capital reserves, were content to hold excess reserves at the ECB—even if they earned no interest—rather than lend out much-needed capital to businesses and consumers. This prompted the ECB to embark on an economic experiment on a grand scale; it reduced short-term policy rates below 0 percent in mid with follow-on rate decreases moving the policy rate to This dramatic policy was intended to provide a jolt to the system.
If deposits were penalized through the direct cost of negative rates, banks should be much more willing to lend.
So far, this policy has failed to work. And this extreme policy has also raised concerns about the potential unintended consequences, such as asset bubbles, if investors hungry for yield seek out ever-riskier investments. Despite the stronger economic picture in the U. The Federal Reserve again responded to slowing growth prospects with its primary monetary policy tool.
At the end of July and again in late September, it reduced the fed funds rate by one-quarter of 1 percent. Importantly, the U. The passage of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act provided fuel to the growth engine in the form of corporate and individual tax cuts and increased government spending.
It verges on conspiratorial. This article is based on the latest YouTube tutorial in our channel , which you can get below:.
In a normal economic and financial environment, these rates tend to be low-single-digit positive percentages e. But anyone who claims that central banks do not make a huge impact on overall interest rates is delusional. By keeping them extremely low or negative, central banks misprice risk , which leads to asset bubbles, unproductive investments, and risky, yield-chasing behavior.
Negative interest rates benefit the asset-owning wealthy elite, worsen wealth and income inequality, and do nothing for the average, middle-income person.
Applying Discounts to Subscriptions
They make a disastrous impact on commercial banks, pension funds, and anyone with an inkling of common sense. Just go to Denmark and ask any bank there! As an investor, you get to pay someone else for the privilege of lending them money. In this case, the market price can remain the same as face value or par value and a simple negative coupon rate will make the yield negative:. In this scenario, you still earn positive interest income from bonds, but the market prices of those bonds get bid up, making the yields negative:.
In real life, most bonds with negative yields are zero-coupon bonds issued by countries like Germany and Switzerland:. And lower interest rates and lower coupon rates often mean that yields will be lower simply because bonds produce less interest income. With appropriate currency hedging, a negative yield can turn into a positive one, such as when U. Traditional bond investing is supposed to be about earning interest income, with some possibility of modest capital appreciation.
For a good example of this casino mentality, take a look at the price of the year Austrian government bonds issued in Because of the long maturity of these bonds, their duration and convexity are very high, making them extremely sensitive to small changes in market yields. Skip to content. We are searching for bonds that pay a negative coupon rate.
How do negative-yielding bonds work?
Here is a good clarification. Like this: Like Loading This entry was posted in Bonds , Uncategorized and tagged bonds , Negative yield. Bookmark the permalink. August 8, at PM. John Porter says:.
Make informed decisions with the FT
Gary, excellent explanation. I posted a comment. Leave a Reply Cancel reply Enter your comment here